The Smu Reviews

Music
Art
Pop Culture
Music / Art / Pop Culture

Edinburgh Fringe Festival 2025

Seeking out the best independent, unsung, and emerging voices in Theatre, Music, and Comedy.

*This page will be updated throughout the festival*


Skip to review:
4’s a Crowd (Or What Not to Do When Stuck in a Bunker During the Apocalypse)
The 80s Movie Mixtape
A Bohemian Banquet
A Year and a Day
art* / a:t / noun
Articulate
Confessions of a Lunatic
The Deadmouse and Peabrain Dreams
Elements
The Family Copoli: A Post-Apocalyptic Burlesque Musical
Gladiatrix
It’s Gonna Blow!
Frankenstein: Afterglow
HAMLET by New York Circus Project
Hidden Powers
Life Cycle of a Star
Mason King – The Mind Spy
Mark Vigeant: The Best Man Show
A Midsummer Night’s Dream
No More Bull
Out of My Wheelhouse
Proust Effect
Queen: The Legend of Queen
Roadkill Bambi
Solve-Along-A-Murder-She-Wrote
Tall Tails
The Unquiet Mind
What If They Ate the Baby?
Women of Rock
You’re Fired! The Musical

All reviews by Susan Sloan







Articulate
Two tightly linked share houses face off in a high-stakes board game battle, with the seemingly trivial prize of a framed photo of the losing team displayed on the winner’s fridge. Beneath the surface lies a mix of competitiveness, old grudges, and clashing personalities. The cast all deliver solid performances and while some of their bickering provides humorous moments, the constant squabbling makes it difficult to fully connect with the characters, even as the final push for victory brings out their true colours.

Finn Hoegh-Guldberg and Penelope Gordon
Buy Tickets


Confessions of a Lunatic
Set in 1890s Scotland, Confessions of a Lunatic is a tense and psychological take on Dracula, written by Lewis Mullan, who also gives a gripping performance as the unravelling Renfield.

Dr Seward – played with quietly compelling charisma by Aydan Macdonald, who makes the most of the piece’s otherwise less showy role – throws himself into the study of his most disturbed patient. Meanwhile Lucy (Elliot Shaw) finds herself drawn into Renfield’s orbit, as Dracula begins to close in.

With effective use of atmospheric staging, reflecting the characters’ increasingly tormented inner worlds, and a script that is at times surprisingly humorous as well as grotesque, this is a dark and inventive spin on a gothic classic.

Nightshade Theatre
Buy Tickets





Frankenstein: Afterglow
What if the story didn’t end on the ice? Frankenstein: Afterglow imagines a world where Victor and his creature survive, locked in a neon-lit struggle over identity, choice, and mortality. Incorporating puppetry and pre-recorded dialogue into an otherwise compelling one-man performance with mixed results, this gothic reimagining brings new ideas to Shelley’s classic.

Spike Rose Productions
Buy Tickets




Hidden Powers
Magician Angus Baskerville returns with Hidden Powers, an entertaining hour blending mind-reading, magic, and affable neurodivergent humour. Several clever tricks involving audience participation leave a real impression – including one where a sheet of paper is torn up and then… well, you’ll have to go along to see for yourself. Comparing his autism to a superpower, Baskerville is funny and full of surprises.

Angus Baskerville

Buy Tickets


It’s Gonna Blow!
Set on the brink of disaster in 79 AD, It’s Gonna Blow! invites audiences to Pompeii’s final public forum – where ancient arguments bubble over and a literal dark cloud of ash, fire, and rock looms overhead. This new historical immersive comedy from Fishing4Chips blends the family-friendly silliness of Horrible Histories with the shaggy-dog saga of its geographic predecessor Up Pompeii!

Entertaining throughout, the show is energetically performed by an excellent cast, most notably Freddie Walker’s withered crone and Yasmine Meaden’s standout performance as the scheming Mayor Faustus. The show is often at its funniest when involving the audience – though these moments are surprisingly small and tightly contained given the immersive premise.

Sean Wareing’s extremely funny pre-show turn as the town crier, welcoming audience members and collecting their “agenda items” for the forum, is also a real highlight. It’s a shame, however, that few (if any) of these improvisational prompts found their way into the main performance. Still, It’s Gonna Blow! delivers a lively and playful spin on impending doom.

Fishing4Chips
Buy Tickets



Mason King – The Mind Spy
Psychological magician Mason King returns with Mind Spy, an interactive blend of mystery and mind reading. Inspired by the real-life Project Stargate, the show invites the audience to become test subjects in demonstrations of thought transmission, remote viewing and precognition.

While the premise is intriguing and the concept well-framed, the delivery can at times feel a little dry, and the slower pacing occasionally gives the audience a bit too long to ponder how the illusions are achieved. Despite this, it’s an enjoyable way to dip your toe into the world of mentalism, and many of the tricks will leave you scratching your head.

Mason King
Buy Tickets



A Midsummer Night’s Dream
Midsummer Night’s Dream set in the Love Island villa is a clever concept, with contestants standing in for lovers and fairies recast as presenters and crew. The decision to stick almost entirely to Shakespeare’s text is ambitious, but it sometimes makes the theme feel tacked on and the humour less consistent than the premise promises. A braver rewrite might have opened it up beyond what feels like a bit of a theatre-kid niche. Still, there are standout touches – Bottom as a smug recruiter, Oberon and Titania as rival hosts, and a lively Puck – making for an inventive if uneven adaptation.

New Stagers
Buy Tickets


No More Bull
No More Bull offers a reimagining of the Minotaur myth, following Ariadne – caught between the Minotaur and hero Theseus – as she discovers the truth behind her family’s fate. The staging, direction, and costuming are all strong, with notable visual moments including striking backlit silhouettes and the cleverly staged chase through the maze. The cast give solid performances throughout, with a highlight being Ariadne’s song to the Minotaur, one of the show’s more heartfelt scenes.

The script feels somewhat conflicted in tone: mostly a serious retelling, but with occasional contemporary, humorous asides that jar slightly – much like the title itself – with the majority of the content. Both the script and songs could push further into either dramatic or comedic territory to help the show land more decisively. Still, with a staging that feels larger in scale than its footprint, this is a slick production that reflects on patriarchy, power and hero worship in an engaging and distinctive way.

Nicholsons Upstage
Buy Tickets







Tall Tails
Tall Tails makes a splash with five mermaids – chronic people-pleasers on a retreat – trying to navigate perfectionism, anxiety, and the choppy waters of love. It’s awash with fishy puns, cheeky humour, and characters whose personalities sparkle as much as their mid-2000s-glam costumes. Channeling spiritual silliness and the tangled fishnets of friendship, this watery comedy will have you floundering with laughter. The last 10–15 minutes are particularly hilarious, sending the audience overboard with joy.

Tall Tails
Buy Tickets


The Unquiet Mind
Directed by Daniela Poch and adapted by Anastasia Stern, The Unquiet Mind offers an interesting approach to Shakespeare’s Hamlet, blending original text with movement and music. Drawing on the influence of Pina Bausch’s Tanztheater, the production shifts focus to Hamlet’s relationships with Gertrude and Ophelia, exploring themes of identity, agency, and inner turmoil.

While the fusion of styles creates some striking moments, the more traditional dramatic elements occasionally dilute the impact. A more fully movement-led approach might have made this ambitious reimagining even more compelling.

The Unquiet Mind
Buy Tickets



Women of Rock
Women of Rock takes the audience on a journey through time with some of the most influential female artists in rock, from the 1960s onwards. Backed by the award-winning Night Owl Band, Reine Beau delivers an energetic, full-throttle performance, with standout moments including a blistering rendition of Janis Joplin’s Piece of My Heart and an equally fierce take on The Runaways’ Cherry Bomb. The show weaves in details about the artists featured, and it’s clear Beau connects with the material on a personal level.

Having seen her in other Night Owl productions, I have always been impressed, but this show truly highlights Beau’s vocals and performance style, perhaps because she is able to bring more of herself to the delivery rather than inhabiting a single artist’s persona. The choice of songs and artists covered was excellent overall, though the inclusion of Addicted to Love as one of two songs representing Tina Turner (the other being the more expected Proud Mary) was a surprising pick – it might have been stronger to swap it for a track more closely associated with Tina, or to feature another artist not already in the line-up.

Either way, the show is a high-energy celebration of the women who defined – and continue to define – rock music, and a reminder of why their contributions deserve greater recognition.

Night Owl
Buy Tickets



Edinburgh Fringe Reviews 2024 »
Edinburgh Fringe Reviews 2023 »
Edinburgh Fringe Reviews 2022 »

All words by Susan Sloan.